How to Negotiate With Influencers as a Brand (Win-Win)

‍

Okay, so, let's be real. Marketing these days? It's a wild ride. You've probably thrown everything at the wall – Facebook ads, TikTok trends, the whole thing – and still, it's like, meh. You're just not seeing that spark, that real growth you were hoping for.

‍

Then you hear about influencers. Everyone's talking about them, how they can totally blow up your brand. You're thinking, "Okay, maybe this is it."

‍

Then you start reaching out, and those price tags? You're left wondering, "Is this even worth it?" It's frustrating, right? You know you need that exposure, that boost, but it feels like you're hitting a brick wall.

‍

Look, you're not alone. Figuring out how to actually work with influencers, without feeling like you're getting ripped off, is tough. 

‍

We're going to break down how to actually negotiate with influencers, so you can walk away feeling like you've got a win-win situation.

‍

How Much Do Influencers Charge?

‍

When you're thinking about working with influencers, it's not a one-size-fits-all thing. You've got these huge names, the mega-influencers, with millions of followers. Then you've got the smaller guys, the micro and nano-influencers. They might not have the same massive reach, but their followers are usually super into what they're saying.

‍

Understanding the different types of influencers and their respective value propositions is the first step towards effective negotiation. You can check our guide on “How Much Does It Cost to Hire an Influencer?”

‍

How to Negotiate Contracts with Influencers?

‍

1. Do Your Research and Due Diligence

‍

When it comes to negotiating with influencers, you can't just wing it. You need some hard numbers to back you up.

‍

You could ask the influencer for screenshots of their analytics, or use a tool like Favikon.

‍

Favikon gives you a really clear picture of their audience and how their content's performing. For instance, you can see things like their engagement rate, average views, and audience demographics. With that data in hand, you can actually set realistic expectations.

You can say, “Based on your stats, we're expecting about X% reach or sales.” It gives you a solid starting point for the negotiation. Plus, you can really drill down into their audience.

‍

Maybe you find out only 50% of their followers are in your target market, like France, or you spot some potential fake followers. Now, you have to tread carefully here. You can't just bluntly accuse them of having fake followers, even if it's kinda common. People get touchy about that.

‍

Instead, you can use that info to justify your offer. You could say something like, “Our main focus is reaching the French audience, and since a significant portion of your reach is outside France, the most we can offer is X. We totally get if that's lower than your usual rate, but we were hoping we could still work something out.”

‍

They might say no. But this approach is way better than just throwing out a lowball number without any explanation. It shows you've done your homework.

‍

And don't forget the scope of work! Make sure everything is crystal clear:

• how many posts,
• what kind of content,
• usage rights,
• any exclusivity,
• how long the campaign will run.

‍

A detailed scope ensures everyone's on the same page and helps justify the compensation you're offering.

‍

2. Share Your Minimum KPI Guarantees

‍

The concept of Key Performance Indicator guarantees is gaining traction in influencer marketing. This involves setting a minimum benchmark for performance, such as video views, and establishing consequences if that benchmark isn't met. While opinions on KPI guarantees are divided, brands are increasingly using them as a way to mitigate risk in influencer collaborations.

‍

But here's the thing: you can't just spring this stuff on influencers at the last minute. You got to be upfront about it, right from the start. Most influencers, they're cool with it as long as you're honest. The real problem comes when you start talking about what happens if they don't hit those numbers. Like, if you tell them they have to completely redo a whole YouTube video? Yeah, that's gonna cause some drama.

‍

Instead, a lot of people are finding that asking for something like an Instagram Story works a lot better. It's way less work for the influencer, and honestly, those link clicks you get from Stories can be super valuable, especially if you're trying to sell something.

‍

Plus, you might even reach a whole new group of people. So, the smart move is to start small. Ask for something reasonable, get everyone on the same page, and then you can build from there. It's all about making sure everyone feels like it's a fair deal, and you're not just throwing money away.

‍

3. Negotiate Beyond Monetary Compensation

‍

Okay, money's obviously a big part of it, but it's not the whole conversation, right? When you're working with someone, especially influencers, you've got to think outside the paycheck. Here's what we mean:

‍

• Hit Those Goals, Get Paid: Instead of just a flat fee, why not tie some of it to how well they actually do? As we mentioned above, if they get a ton of clicks or good KPIs, they get a bigger bonus. Makes sense, right? Everyone wins when the campaign does well.
• Let Them Earn on Sales: Affiliate links are awesome. They put in the work, and they get a cut of every sale they bring in. It's super clear and easy to track, especially if you're selling products.
• Content That Keeps Giving: Think about letting them use the stuff they make for you on their own channels, too. That way, they build up their portfolio, and you can even grab some of that content to use yourself. It's like double dipping, but in a good way.
• Shout Out: Don't just post their stuff and forget about it. Actually promote their content on your own pages! Share it, boost it, get it in front of more people. 
• Give Them the VIP Treatment: Everyone loves feeling special. Offer them exclusive stuff, like early access to products or invites to cool events. That's the kind of thing that builds strong relationships and gives them killer content to share.

‍

Knowing When to Walk Away (and When to Compromise)

‍

While aiming for a win-win outcome, brands must also be prepared to walk away if negotiation reaches an impasse or if the influencer's demands are unreasonable or unsustainable. 

‍

Setting clear budget limits and understanding your non-negotiables is crucial. However, equally important is knowing when to compromise and find creative solutions to bridge the gap. Sometimes, a slight increase in budget or a revised scope of work can unlock a valuable partnership.

‍

Common Influencer Negotiations Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

1. Thinking More Followers = More Value (And Paying Way Too Much)

‍

Look, everyone sees those big numbers and thinks, "Wow, they must be super popular!" But just because someone has a million followers doesn't mean anyone's actually paying attention. You could be paying a fortune for an influencer whose audience is basically asleep.

‍

The Fix: Forget just looking at the follower count. Use tools like Favikon and dig into the engagement and reach out. Check:

‍

• How many likes, comments, shares are they getting?
• Who are these people following them?
• Are they your target audience?
• Has this influencer actually run successful campaigns before?

‍

2. Forgetting Who Owns the Stuff They Make (And Getting Sued Later)

‍

You think, "Cool, they made a video for us! We can use it anywhere!" Nope. You might be breaking the law. A lot of brands just assume they can take that content and run with it, and that's a recipe for legal trouble.

‍

The Fix: Get it in writing. Make sure the contract spells out exactly who owns the content. Check:

‍

• Can you use it for ads?
• Can you put it on your website?
• Can you reuse it in a year?

‍

3. Being Super Vague About What You Want (And Getting Bad Results)

‍

You tell an influencer, "Just make a cool post!" and then you get something totally off-brand. It happens all the time. Brands don't set clear expectations, and then they're stuck with content they can't use.

‍

The Fix: Be specific. Figure out your goals and tell the influencer exactly what you need. Tell them:

‍

• How many posts do you want?
• What kind of style are you going for?
• What messages do you need to get across?
• How are you going to measure success? 

‍

Structuring the Influencer Agreement

‍

Once negotiation is complete and mutually agreeable terms are reached, formalize the agreement in a clear and comprehensive contract. The influencer agreement should outline:

‍

1. Scope of Work: Detailed description of deliverables, including the number of posts, content formats, platforms, posting schedule, and any specific campaign messaging or hashtags.
2. Compensation and Payment Terms: Clearly stated monetary compensation, payment schedule, and details of any non-monetary benefits (e.g., product seeding, affiliate commissions).
3. Usage Rights and Exclusivity: Specify content usage rights for both the brand and the influencer, including duration and platforms. Outline any exclusivity clauses, preventing the influencer from working with direct competitors for a defined period.
4. Performance Metrics and Reporting: Define key performance indicators (KPIs) and reporting requirements for the influencer to track campaign performance and demonstrate results.
5. Compliance and Disclosure: Ensure the agreement addresses legal compliance, including disclosure requirements for sponsored content and adherence to advertising guidelines.
6. Termination Clause: Outline conditions and procedures for contract termination by either party.

‍